Sunday, October 30, 2011

Mennonite Literature and Mennonite Theology

Susie Guenther Loewen recently wrote a thoughtful blog post entitled The Gap in Mennonite Literature in which she lamented the thin to nonexistent portrayal of Mennonite theology in most contemporary Mennonite literature. While she does not wish to negate the difficult experiences of coming to voice articulated in this literature, such as Nomi Nickel's experience in A Complicated Kindness by Miriam Toews, she notes that younger Mennonites often find a supportive community in their Mennonite heritage for artistic creation. Her solution--more Mennonite writing from a new group of writers!

What do you think? Have you noticed this gap?

How does the Mennonite literature you've read contrast with or illuminate your own experience as a Mennonite or with Mennonites?

Does it serve to reinforce stereotypes or to open new perspectives?

When a literature is labeled as "ethnic" or "cultural," does that mean its theology will be of minimal significance?

Can creative, vibrant theology find its way into literature?

Does Mennonite Literary creation depend upon the portrayal of an "oppressive" religious structure that must be overthrown to liberate the "individual voice?"

2 comments:

  1. Yes, I have noticed the gap!! I started reading Amish literature and found that I love it. Haven't tried the romanaces yet as I am not a big romance fan but I love books that consider moral issues and tell about customs. Right now I am reading 'I am Hutterite' by Mary-Ann Kirkby. Since so many of my grandfather's side were Mennnonites, I searched for Mennonite literature and only came up with one writer. I plan to read some of Kim Vogel Sawyer's books soon, but wondered are there other writers? These are my roots and I would love to know more about them.

    Carol Wong

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Carol,

    I suggest you check out www.mennonitewriting.org
    This is the website for the Center for Mennonite Writing, which I edit. It publishes an online journal every other month, and also has lots of resources for the study of Mennonite Writing. Under the section "Encyclopedia" you will see Ervin Beck's bibliographies of Mennonite Literature in the U.S. and Canada. This will get you started!

    ReplyDelete